Movie Review: The Forge – A Story That Stirs the Heart (Even If the Critics Missed It)

Last weekend, my ten-year-old son and I watched The Forge—a new faith-based film that’s been stirring up quite the mixed bag of reviews. Some critics have called it predictable. Others have dismissed it as overly sentimental or too simplistic. But as we sat there together, watching this story unfold, I realized something important: sometimes, the very things the critics scoff at are what families like mine deeply value.

Yes, The Forge may not be what Hollywood calls a cinematic masterpiece—but that’s not what it’s trying to be. And that’s precisely why it worked so well for us.

A Story of Redemption That Resonates

The Forge follows a young man grappling with disappointment, directionlessness, and the weight of not living up to others' expectations—or his own. Without giving away too much, it’s a story that draws from the deep well of redemption, second chances, and discovering purpose through the refining fires of adversity. It’s got that classic Kendrick Brothers formula—faith-driven, heartwarming, and unapologetically hopeful.

For me, the themes hit home. But what made the experience even more special was seeing my son—ten years old and still young enough to be captivated by good storytelling—completely engaged. No fidgeting. No wandering off to grab snacks. No asking, "Is it almost over?" That’s rare. And it told me everything I needed to know about whether the film worked.

One line from the film that really stood out was, "You’ve been asking God to change your circumstances, but maybe He’s trying to change you through your circumstances." That’s not just a good line—it’s a whole sermon in a sentence.

The Power of Men’s Ministry

One aspect of The Forge that really struck a chord with me personally was its emphasis on mentorship and men’s ministry. Over the years, I’ve been deeply shaped by the time I’ve spent with other men in intentional, Christ-centered community. Men’s ministry has been a refining fire in my own life—a place where I’ve been challenged, encouraged, sharpened, and reminded of who I truly am in Christ.

Watching the film’s portrayal of older men pouring into younger ones, speaking life, calling out truth, and walking alongside those who feel stuck or lost—it reminded me of the kind of discipleship that changed my own trajectory. It reminded me that we don't grow in isolation. We grow when others call us higher.

That part of the film wasn’t just inspiring—it was personal.

Kendrick Brothers Easter Eggs Galore

Now, for the longtime Kendrick Brothers fans—The Forge is full of hidden gems and callbacks to the earlier films. Blink and you might miss them. It’s like a cinematic scavenger hunt for those of us who’ve followed their journey from the early Flywheel days to the more polished productions like Overcomer.

Jay Austin Motors? Yes, it’s back. That iconic name from Flywheel makes a reappearance, and for those of us who remember where it all began, it feels like a quiet nod to faithfulness and humble beginnings.

But it doesn’t stop there. Watch closely and you’ll catch references to War Room, Courageous, Overcomer, and even a few familiar faces in supporting roles. Whether it’s a subtle line of dialogue, a logo in the background, or a character name that rings a bell, the film invites loyal fans into a deeper layer of appreciation. It’s like the Kendrick Brothers are saying, “We remember where we’ve come from—and we’re still building on it.”

These Easter eggs aren’t just for fun (though they are fun). They also serve as a reminder that their films are part of a bigger tapestry—a long-form narrative of transformation, faith, forgiveness, and purpose. The Forge carries that legacy forward with fresh energy and renewed conviction.

Addressing the Criticisms

Let’s talk about the criticisms, though. Are some of the plot points familiar? Sure. Do the characters speak a bit more like they’re giving sermons than having casual conversation? Occasionally. But here’s the thing—The Forge isn’t trying to be subtle. It’s trying to be clear.

In a world where so many movies bury truth beneath layers of cynicism or sarcasm, this one dares to be straightforward. It dares to say that faith matters. That people can change. That God still forges beauty out of brokenness.

Another critique I’ve seen is that the film is “too clean,” too idealistic, too safe. And maybe that’s true in a way. But can I just say—after wading through the moral minefield that is most modern media, I’ll gladly take a movie that I can watch with my child without having to pre-screen it, skip scenes, or explain inappropriate jokes.

The Forge is family-friendly not because it’s shallow, but because it’s thoughtful about what it’s putting on the screen. It shows what real courage, forgiveness, and obedience can look like—not in perfect people, but in imperfect people who say yes to God anyway.

What It Gave Us

What The Forge gave us wasn’t just a nice night on the couch—it was a doorway into conversation. After the movie, my son asked questions like, “What does it mean to be refined?” and “Why do people give up on their dreams?”

We talked about how hard things shape us, about what it means to trust God even when the path doesn’t make sense, and about how mistakes don’t define us—they refine us.

Another line that stuck with me was, “Your past doesn’t disqualify you—it prepares you.” What a powerful truth to offer the next generation. And what a powerful reminder for us, too.

Final Thoughts

The Forge might not win over the film critics, but it won us over. It reminded me that movies don’t have to be perfect to be powerful. Sometimes, they just need to be honest. Hopeful. Anchored in truth.

And for men like me—who have been shaped and supported through godly brotherhood—the film’s message is more than inspirational. It’s a reminder to keep forging ahead and to keep showing up for the next generation. Especially when one of them is sitting right next to you on the couch, watching.

If you’re wondering whether this is a movie the whole family can enjoy—yes, it absolutely is. My wife watched it with us, and she was moved by the story, the sincerity, and the heart behind it. The film doesn’t just speak to men—it speaks to parents, spouses, and anyone who’s ever struggled to trust God with the unknown. It’s well-rounded, emotionally engaging, and full of moments that spark reflection and conversation.

So if you’re a parent wondering whether The Forge is worth watching with your kids—my answer is yes. Watch it. Talk about it. Let the themes settle in. Look for the Easter eggs. Laugh at the callbacks. And let your heart be stirred again by the simple, steady truth: God’s not finished with us yet.

In a world that’s trying hard to dull the light, The Forge dares to shine.

Watch the trailer